# Guestbook — Railspike debug log

## 2026-11-11T22:20:00Z — Step 1

**Necessary/useful instructions**
- `RAILSPIKE.md` Original Query / Understood Intent rule: the query predates the brainstorm, so Understood Intent carried the decisions (keepsake, paper book, sticky notes parked). Retain.
- `AGENTS.md` standing P2 enrollment: removed the need to ask about study selection. Retain.
- Step 1 "Open questions" were not required by the template but surfaced naturally in the Recommendation; the template could name a slot for questions deferred to Step 2. Clarify.

**Redundant/unnecessary instructions**
- No supported findings.

**Inapplicable instructions**
- Step 1 `/new` reminder: discussion preceded the Step 1 task, so it applies; no issue.

**Uncertain assessments**
- Extended-estimate rules for Option C: an option likely beyond one cycle still needs a whole-cycle number; a "split likely" marker might read more honestly than 0.90.

## 2026-11-14T02:10:00Z — Step 2

**Necessary/useful instructions**
- `RAILSPIKE.md` Enhancement Requests: the thread-access request arrived with the approval; recording it in Step 1 kept the approval and the scope change apart. Retain.
- Step 2 shared component inventory: led to `PageNavigation::numbered` (from `/gallery/`) for readable page addresses instead of a new pager. Retain.

**Redundant/unnecessary instructions**
- No supported findings.

**Inapplicable instructions**
- Known user or environment: the request names no user or environment beyond the maintainer's normal release check.

**Uncertain assessments**
- Step 2 has no slot for answers to Step 1's open questions; a "Decisions" section was added by hand. The template could name one.

## 2026-11-14T02:20:00Z — Step 3

**Necessary/useful instructions**
- Step 3 "Canonical components/API contracts" bullet: checking it found `reply_form.php`'s existing `return_to`, which removed a planned redirect change. Retain.
- Completion Contract deployment field: surfaced that the guestbook thread must exist before its ID can go into the site profile, which became Stage 5. Retain.

**Redundant/unnecessary instructions**
- No supported findings.

**Inapplicable instructions**
- Known-user replay stage: Step 2 names no reported failure to replay.

**Uncertain assessments**
- The one-page limit and full per-stage fields pull against each other at five stages; this plan runs slightly over a page.

## 2026-11-14T02:30:00Z — Step 4

**Necessary/useful instructions**
- `step4_implementation_before.md` planning-commit gate: kept plans, ledger and summary in separate commits with no judgment calls. Retain.
- Shared implementation standards, canonical component reuse: found the existing `return_to` and `canonicalReplyUrl`, so the client needed no change. Retain.
- `AGENTS.md` test scope (smoke plus touched classes): kept each stage's checks short. Retain.

**Redundant/unnecessary instructions**
- No supported findings.

**Inapplicable instructions**
- Known-user replay: no reported failure to replay.

**Uncertain assessments**
- A final stage that waits on production (Stage 5) has no clear place in the stage-commit cadence; the summary marks it pending rather than committing an empty stage. The workflow could name this case.
- The Step 4 commit count rule (`1 + stages`) cannot be met until Stage 5 lands.
