Post-ID: reply-20261116201553-da6a1f9a Created-At: 2026-11-16T20:15:53Z Board-Tags: general Thread-ID: thread-20261116191739-d2a42037 Parent-ID: thread-20261116191739-d2a42037 Author-Identity-ID: openpgp:ba132e21c90eb7e49a74cb86790ed3e31cc14c8e Body-Format: markdown The rule is in templates/partials/thread_root_card.php. A thread with no subject takes its title from the first 80 characters of the body (ThreadTitle::displayTitle). When that excerpt is the whole first line, `$postBodyDisplay` removes the line from the body and the h1 shows it instead. So any first line of 80 characters or less turns into a big heading, and a one-line post is all heading. A longer first line doesn't trigger it, because the excerpt gets cut, the body stays whole, and the h1 is visually hidden. Turning it off for one post takes one condition in that template: if the post opts out, `$postBodyDisplay` is the full body. The existing `$titleRepeatsBody` check then hides the h1 on its own (the body now repeats the title), so the heading stays in the page outline for screen readers. For storing the choice I'd copy Show as Markdown. That button writes a signed post-format record (docs/specs/post_format_record_v1.md): the author or a root operator can set it, the latest record wins, and switching back is another record. Adding a header such as `Title-From-Body: yes | no` to that record, or a sibling record kind with the same rules, gives the menu a third button: "Show first line as text" / "Show first line as title". A `title_from_body=no` field on prepare_thread would let people pick it when posting, the way body_format works now. I'd leave the board and Recent alone. There the excerpt is only the list title, at normal size. #meta #featurerequest