Text column edges

No-JavaScript basic access — Railspike debug log

2026-10-19T17:22:01Z — Step 1

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step1_solution_assessment.md, Structure: comparing approaches clarified that guest continuity and interface resilience are separate decisions. Retain.

  • step1_solution_assessment.md, Next: the approval gate keeps this request to assessment; no Step 2 or application changes were made. Retain.

  • RAILSPIKE.md, Debug state: root marker presence resolved enabled mode, recorded in the assessment. Retain durable state.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Step 4 branching, organization, and commit requirements do not apply to this unapproved Step 1 draft. Planning files remain uncommitted.

Uncertain assessments

  • The one-page limit does not specify rendering. The assessment is concise Markdown; exact printed pagination is unknown. Consider a word budget if literal pagination matters.

2026-10-19T17:23:27Z — Step 2

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step2_feature_description.md, Known user or environment and Completion boundary: requiring actual disabled-script entry and error recovery prevents treating native form markup as completed browser support. Retain.

  • step2_feature_description.md, Shared component inventory: existing layout, board, forms, handlers, and access gates provide a shared surface rather than requiring a second interface. Retain.

  • RAILSPIKE.md, approval and debug recovery: inherited enabled state and recorded Step 1 approval; Step 2 remains uncommitted and no Step 3 was opened. Retain.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Documentation-only scope restrictions do not apply to this proposed application feature.

Uncertain assessments

  • The concise-document requirement and extensive required fields compete for space; physical page count remains rendering-dependent. Consider a word budget.

2026-10-19T18:27:29Z — Step 3

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step3_development_plan_before.md, Before Checklist: confirming Step 2 approval prevented treating the premature Step 3 message as approval of an unwritten artifact. Retain.

  • step3_development_plan_do.md, Completion Contract and known environment acceptance: actual Chromium with JavaScript disabled reproduced blocked inline disclosure, successful standalone guest thread/reply posting, retained drafts after rejected image-reference text, correction/success, and protected HTTP 401 with misleading reconnecting text. Those findings focus stages on native interaction and truthful recovery. Retain browser-specific evidence requirements.

  • step3_development_plan_do.md, risks before dependent work: inspecting BoardPageController exposed that pagination only exists for QDB. The plan explicitly calls out new default-forum pagination to satisfy approved Step 2, rather than claiming an existing paginator merely needs repair. Retain.

  • step3_development_plan_after.md, stage sizing and approval: five bounded stages, uncommitted draft, no Step 4 opened. Retain.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Documentation-only verification does not apply; this is application work.

  • Planned signature/schema changes are unnecessary: existing controller/helper contracts support the intended work.

Uncertain assessments

  • step3_development_plan_do.md requests Completion Contract before Key Risks, while RAILSPIKE.md says Step 3 begins with Key Risks. The plan follows the detailed file's explicit order and places risks immediately after the contract. Clarify the entrypoint to say risks belong near the top.

  • One-page rendering remains unspecified; this plan is 679 words with flat stage fields. A word budget would make the constraint reproducible.

Baseline evidence boundary

  • Temporary local fixture and browser probe, outside the project, used Chrome /opt/google/chrome/chrome through Playwright with javaScriptEnabled:false; records, read model, sessions, and caches were isolated and cleaned.

  • Final probe passed native New Post entry, guest thread creation, Reply-link entry, guest reply creation, both validation corrections, and observed protected denial. Clicking the inline prompt left its form invisible. Pagination was absent; source confirmed it is QDB-only. Reload persistence, full navigation/theme coverage, and production behavior were not claimed as tested.

  • An earlier probe used a non-recognized image marker and consequently did not trigger validation; corrected to Image-v1: before recording validation results. No application files were changed by probes.

2026-11-16 — Step 3 revision

Mode: enabled, inherited from the 2026-10-19 entries.

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step3_development_plan_before.md "Confirm Step 2 is approved": the user's "approved step 2" matched no pending gate (Step 2 was approved 2026-10-19; the related Windows ME cycle is at Step 1). It was read as reconfirming nojs Step 2 and authorizing the Step 3 rewrite, and explicitly not as Windows ME Step 1 approval.

  • The old draft's own note, "Revalidate against current code before resuming": with 1,124 intervening commits, a live baseline overturned three of five draft stages (pagination landed, inline composer fixed via @media (scripting: enabled), posting covered by composers.mjs).

  • Effort "Existing cycles join at their next checkpoint without invented earlier scores" plus the extended-mode legacy rule: a first snapshot at the Step 3 handoff with extended estimates disabled.

  • AGENTS.md "replay that condition or report it unverified": kept the members-only "Reconnecting" replay and the Lynx posting replay as acceptance evidence.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Schema and signature planning: no changes needed.

Uncertain assessments

  • Running the browser checks needed node_modules. The pinned playwright-core@1.58.1 (declared devDependency) was copied from a sibling checkout instead of fetched; it is gitignored and adds no new dependency.

  • board_compose_focus.mjs:61 times out on two runs on unmodified main. The cause is not yet known; Stage 1 diagnoses it.

  • Moving "old-engine-safe hiding" out of this cycle reverses what I told the user one turn earlier. The fresh baseline shows modern no-script hiding already works, so the old-engine technique belongs to the Windows ME cycle.

Baseline evidence boundary

  • Chromium (/opt/google/chrome/chrome) through Playwright with scripts off, against the local dev server (127.0.0.1:8000, this checkout). Read-only probe plus one failed-validation submit, which wrote nothing. Probe scripts live in the session scratchpad, not the repo.

  • Pagination and members-only denial were not exercised in a browser. Stage 1 seeds them.

2026-11-16 — Step 4

Mode: enabled, inherited.

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step4_implementation_before.md planning-commit gate and organization rule: moved the four nojs artifacts into the feature folder and repaired links. Uncommitted Windows ME plans and the ledger stayed out of the commit.

  • step4_implementation_do.md "reuse canonical components": led to reusing image_browser_router.php (its flags.json already switches members-only) and the existing @media (scripting: none) first-paint block, instead of new routers or script-driven toggles.

  • step4_implementation_after.md item 7, "identify reproduced baseline failures; a focused pass is never a full-suite result": shaped the final table (smoke 159/162 long-standing, board_compose_focus baseline failure, full suite not run).

  • AGENTS.md "replay that condition or explicitly report it unverified": kept the Lynx result honest. Form submission passed; keyboard discovery was reported as not achieved rather than passed.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Extended stage estimates: disabled for this legacy cycle.

  • Deployment and migration checks: no schema, authentication or deployment change.

Uncertain assessments

  • The study ledger is one file shared by concurrent cycles. Committing only the nojs section needed a hand-built index entry (git update-index --cacheinfo), because git add -p is unavailable and the hunks were adjacent. Railspike could say how to scope ledger commits when another cycle's planning edits are pending in the same file.

  • Two proposed concept entries were merged into one (no_script_presentation.md) because they share a mechanism. The plan named them separately.

  • A safety check blocked an rm -rf whose target came from command substitution. Temporary fixtures were then removed by literal path.