Repository source: docs/plans/nojs_basic_access/nojs_basic_access_debug_log.md
No-JavaScript basic access — Railspike debug log
2026-10-19T17:22:01Z — Step 1
Necessary/useful instructions
step1_solution_assessment.md, Structure: comparing approaches clarified that guest continuity and interface resilience are separate decisions. Retain.step1_solution_assessment.md, Next: the approval gate keeps this request to assessment; no Step 2 or application changes were made. Retain.RAILSPIKE.md, Debug state: root marker presence resolved enabled mode, recorded in the assessment. Retain durable state.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
Step 4 branching, organization, and commit requirements do not apply to this unapproved Step 1 draft. Planning files remain uncommitted.
Uncertain assessments
The one-page limit does not specify rendering. The assessment is concise Markdown; exact printed pagination is unknown. Consider a word budget if literal pagination matters.
2026-10-19T17:23:27Z — Step 2
Necessary/useful instructions
step2_feature_description.md, Known user or environment and Completion boundary: requiring actual disabled-script entry and error recovery prevents treating native form markup as completed browser support. Retain.step2_feature_description.md, Shared component inventory: existing layout, board, forms, handlers, and access gates provide a shared surface rather than requiring a second interface. Retain.RAILSPIKE.md, approval and debug recovery: inherited enabled state and recorded Step 1 approval; Step 2 remains uncommitted and no Step 3 was opened. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
Documentation-only scope restrictions do not apply to this proposed application feature.
Uncertain assessments
The concise-document requirement and extensive required fields compete for space; physical page count remains rendering-dependent. Consider a word budget.
2026-10-19T18:27:29Z — Step 3
Necessary/useful instructions
step3_development_plan_before.md, Before Checklist: confirming Step 2 approval prevented treating the premature Step 3 message as approval of an unwritten artifact. Retain.step3_development_plan_do.md, Completion Contract and known environment acceptance: actual Chromium with JavaScript disabled reproduced blocked inline disclosure, successful standalone guest thread/reply posting, retained drafts after rejected image-reference text, correction/success, and protected HTTP 401 with misleading reconnecting text. Those findings focus stages on native interaction and truthful recovery. Retain browser-specific evidence requirements.step3_development_plan_do.md, risks before dependent work: inspecting BoardPageController exposed that pagination only exists for QDB. The plan explicitly calls out new default-forum pagination to satisfy approved Step 2, rather than claiming an existing paginator merely needs repair. Retain.step3_development_plan_after.md, stage sizing and approval: five bounded stages, uncommitted draft, no Step 4 opened. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
Documentation-only verification does not apply; this is application work.
Planned signature/schema changes are unnecessary: existing controller/helper contracts support the intended work.
Uncertain assessments
step3_development_plan_do.mdrequests Completion Contract before Key Risks, whileRAILSPIKE.mdsays Step 3 begins with Key Risks. The plan follows the detailed file's explicit order and places risks immediately after the contract. Clarify the entrypoint to say risks belong near the top.One-page rendering remains unspecified; this plan is 679 words with flat stage fields. A word budget would make the constraint reproducible.
Baseline evidence boundary
Temporary local fixture and browser probe, outside the project, used Chrome
/opt/google/chrome/chromethrough Playwright withjavaScriptEnabled:false; records, read model, sessions, and caches were isolated and cleaned.Final probe passed native New Post entry, guest thread creation, Reply-link entry, guest reply creation, both validation corrections, and observed protected denial. Clicking the inline prompt left its form invisible. Pagination was absent; source confirmed it is QDB-only. Reload persistence, full navigation/theme coverage, and production behavior were not claimed as tested.
An earlier probe used a non-recognized image marker and consequently did not trigger validation; corrected to
Image-v1:before recording validation results. No application files were changed by probes.
2026-11-16 — Step 3 revision
Mode: enabled, inherited from the 2026-10-19 entries.
Necessary/useful instructions
step3_development_plan_before.md"Confirm Step 2 is approved": the user's "approved step 2" matched no pending gate (Step 2 was approved 2026-10-19; the related Windows ME cycle is at Step 1). It was read as reconfirming nojs Step 2 and authorizing the Step 3 rewrite, and explicitly not as Windows ME Step 1 approval.The old draft's own note, "Revalidate against current code before resuming": with 1,124 intervening commits, a live baseline overturned three of five draft stages (pagination landed, inline composer fixed via
@media (scripting: enabled), posting covered bycomposers.mjs).Effort "Existing cycles join at their next checkpoint without invented earlier scores" plus the extended-mode legacy rule: a first snapshot at the Step 3 handoff with extended estimates disabled.
AGENTS.md "replay that condition or report it unverified": kept the members-only "Reconnecting" replay and the Lynx posting replay as acceptance evidence.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
Schema and signature planning: no changes needed.
Uncertain assessments
Running the browser checks needed
node_modules. The pinnedplaywright-core@1.58.1(declared devDependency) was copied from a sibling checkout instead of fetched; it is gitignored and adds no new dependency.board_compose_focus.mjs:61times out on two runs on unmodifiedmain. The cause is not yet known; Stage 1 diagnoses it.Moving "old-engine-safe hiding" out of this cycle reverses what I told the user one turn earlier. The fresh baseline shows modern no-script hiding already works, so the old-engine technique belongs to the Windows ME cycle.
Baseline evidence boundary
Chromium (
/opt/google/chrome/chrome) through Playwright with scripts off, against the local dev server (127.0.0.1:8000, this checkout). Read-only probe plus one failed-validation submit, which wrote nothing. Probe scripts live in the session scratchpad, not the repo.Pagination and members-only denial were not exercised in a browser. Stage 1 seeds them.
2026-11-16 — Step 4
Mode: enabled, inherited.
Necessary/useful instructions
step4_implementation_before.mdplanning-commit gate and organization rule: moved the four nojs artifacts into the feature folder and repaired links. Uncommitted Windows ME plans and the ledger stayed out of the commit.step4_implementation_do.md"reuse canonical components": led to reusingimage_browser_router.php(itsflags.jsonalready switches members-only) and the existing@media (scripting: none)first-paint block, instead of new routers or script-driven toggles.step4_implementation_after.mditem 7, "identify reproduced baseline failures; a focused pass is never a full-suite result": shaped the final table (smoke 159/162 long-standing,board_compose_focusbaseline failure, full suite not run).AGENTS.md "replay that condition or explicitly report it unverified": kept the Lynx result honest. Form submission passed; keyboard discovery was reported as not achieved rather than passed.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
Extended stage estimates: disabled for this legacy cycle.
Deployment and migration checks: no schema, authentication or deployment change.
Uncertain assessments
The study ledger is one file shared by concurrent cycles. Committing only the nojs section needed a hand-built index entry (
git update-index --cacheinfo), becausegit add -pis unavailable and the hunks were adjacent. Railspike could say how to scope ledger commits when another cycle's planning edits are pending in the same file.Two proposed concept entries were merged into one (
no_script_presentation.md) because they share a mechanism. The plan named them separately.A safety check blocked an
rm -rfwhose target came from command substitution. Temporary fixtures were then removed by literal path.