Repository source: docs/plans/pledge_campaigns/pledge_campaigns_debug_log.md
Pledge campaigns debug log
2026-11-16T02:30Z — Step 1
Necessary/useful instructions
AGENTS.md"Current retraction coordination": reading the handoff and the retraction concept showed that retraction deletes prose, which contradicts the draft spec's "withdrawn pledges stay visible". Retain.AGENTS.md"Implementation standards" (inspect existing implementations first): surfaced the three directive readers andEventStatus::forThreads(), which decided the recommendation. Retain.step1_solution_assessment.mdStructure (Original Query, options with one paragraph each): kept a long design conversation down to one decision. Retain.docs/railspike/docs/concepts.mdPlanning: prompted naming a proposed "pledge campaign" concept instead of linking a missing file. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
RAILSPIKE.mdExperimental Effort Estimation: intake and Step 1 snapshots are equal when both follow inspection, as an earlier log in this project also noted. Suggest one combined line in that case.RAILSPIKE.mdRailspike Debug Mode and Effort Estimation together are longer than the Step 1 instructions they accompany. Suggest moving recovery detail out of the entry file.
Inapplicable instructions
Documentation-only scope: this cycle is an application change.
Follow-up Cycles Before Merge: no earlier branch exists for this feature.
Uncertain assessments
"Original Query: do not summarize or omit anything": the request was a spoken, multi-turn conversation. The first message and two later decisions were kept with dictation artifacts cleaned; the rest lives in the linked spec. Whether that satisfies the rule is unclear.
The Step 1 limit of one page: the artifact runs slightly over because of three options with estimates.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session; recorded as such.
2026-11-16T02:40Z — Step 2
Necessary/useful instructions
step2_feature_description.mdStructure, "Shared component inventory": readingThreadTheme.php,EventStatus.phpandVerifiedAttribution.phpanswered the unverified-pledge question from existing behaviour instead of opinion. Retain.PRINCIPLES.md"Accommodate first, verify later" (viaAGENTS.md): set the shape of the answer, shown but not counted. Retain.step2_feature_description.mdCompletion boundary and Known user: produced the iPhone SE release condition. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mdEnhancement Requests: kept the plain mock-up theme visible as pending instead of dropping it. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mdDurable state and recovery: the Step 1 fields restored debug and study state in a new session without questions. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
step2_feature_description.mdrepeats the debug and effort pointers thatRAILSPIKE.mdalready requires on step entry. Suggest one line linking both.
Inapplicable instructions
Documentation-only delivery scope fields: application change.
Follow-up Cycles Before Merge: no predecessor cycle.
Uncertain assessments
"≤1 page" and "no mockups": the artifact runs past a page because Step 1 handed two decisions to Step 2, and it links a mock-up canvas without embedding one. Whether a decisions section belongs in Step 2 or in a Step 1 revision is unclear.
Planning-commit rule: Step 1 was committed early by explicit exception; Step 2 is left uncommitted. The instructions do not say which rule a resumed cycle follows after such an exception.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session; recorded as such.
2026-11-16T03:00Z — Step 3
Necessary/useful instructions
step3_development_plan_do.md"Canonical components/API contracts touched" per stage: forced a read ofThreadRepository::replyPostsByThreadId, which showed thread rows already carrybody,retracted_at,attribution_countedandauthor_identity_id. The totals reader needs no query. Retain.step3_development_plan_do.mdCompletion Contract, release condition: kept the iPhone SE check visible as pending instead of implied by tests. Retain.RAILSPIKE.md"do not manufacture approval from agent-authored scope": prompted recording the maintainer's delegation verbatim, with its boundary, before self-approving. Retain; consider naming delegated approval as a supported, labelled state.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
step3_development_plan_after.mdstep 5 "Stop and wait": replaced for this cycle by the recorded delegation.Known user replay stage: the named environment (iPhone SE on zenmemes.com) cannot be reached from this session; recorded as pending, not replayed.
Uncertain assessments
Whether "refinements within scope" (amount field instead of a switch; reason shown to all readers) should have returned to Step 2. Both were named or allowed by Step 2 text, so they were recorded in Step 3. With a self-approving agent this judgment has no second reader.
The plan runs over one page.
2026-11-16T03:15Z — Step 4
Necessary/useful instructions
step4_implementation_do.mdStage Boundary Protocol (verify, update summary, commit, then next stage): kept four reviewable commits in an unattended run with no human between stages. Retain.implementation_standards.md"Complete the recorded outcome through its ordinary entry": running the flow in a browser found the amount field hidden in the collapsed reply box, which every PHP test had passed. Retain.implementation_standards.md"Open the handoff with unverified outcomes": shaped the PR and the checklist around the pending iPhone check and the no-name finding. Retain.AGENTS.mdTests: the smoke set plus named classes ran in about a minute per stage. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
step4_implementation_before.md"Do not add the ledger or summary to the planning commit" while the organization rule asks for repaired references: the ledger's links to moved plans had to wait for the Stage 1 commit. Suggest allowing link-only ledger fixes in the planning commit.
Inapplicable instructions
Documentation-only verification rules.
AGENTS.mdnavigation icons, third-party code and retraction coordination: no navigation item, dependency or retraction change. (npm installfetched only the already declaredplaywright-coreinto the ignorednode_modules/.)
Uncertain assessments
Delegated self-approval: every gate in this cycle after Step 1 was passed by its author. The gates still forced written decisions and a recorded boundary, but they did not supply a second reader. One consequential finding (a no-JavaScript pledge has no name, so it is not counted) follows from a Step 2 decision the author approved alone. Whether Railspike should name this mode, and require the handoff to list self-approved decisions, is for the maintainer.
The separate log-only commit after the final stage: followed as written.