Text column edges

Pledge campaigns debug log

2026-11-16T02:30Z — Step 1

Necessary/useful instructions

  • AGENTS.md "Current retraction coordination": reading the handoff and the retraction concept showed that retraction deletes prose, which contradicts the draft spec's "withdrawn pledges stay visible". Retain.

  • AGENTS.md "Implementation standards" (inspect existing implementations first): surfaced the three directive readers and EventStatus::forThreads(), which decided the recommendation. Retain.

  • step1_solution_assessment.md Structure (Original Query, options with one paragraph each): kept a long design conversation down to one decision. Retain.

  • docs/railspike/docs/concepts.md Planning: prompted naming a proposed "pledge campaign" concept instead of linking a missing file. Retain.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • RAILSPIKE.md Experimental Effort Estimation: intake and Step 1 snapshots are equal when both follow inspection, as an earlier log in this project also noted. Suggest one combined line in that case.

  • RAILSPIKE.md Railspike Debug Mode and Effort Estimation together are longer than the Step 1 instructions they accompany. Suggest moving recovery detail out of the entry file.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Documentation-only scope: this cycle is an application change.

  • Follow-up Cycles Before Merge: no earlier branch exists for this feature.

Uncertain assessments

  • "Original Query: do not summarize or omit anything": the request was a spoken, multi-turn conversation. The first message and two later decisions were kept with dictation artifacts cleaned; the rest lives in the linked spec. Whether that satisfies the rule is unclear.

  • The Step 1 limit of one page: the artifact runs slightly over because of three options with estimates.

  • R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session; recorded as such.

2026-11-16T02:40Z — Step 2

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step2_feature_description.md Structure, "Shared component inventory": reading ThreadTheme.php, EventStatus.php and VerifiedAttribution.php answered the unverified-pledge question from existing behaviour instead of opinion. Retain.

  • PRINCIPLES.md "Accommodate first, verify later" (via AGENTS.md): set the shape of the answer, shown but not counted. Retain.

  • step2_feature_description.md Completion boundary and Known user: produced the iPhone SE release condition. Retain.

  • RAILSPIKE.md Enhancement Requests: kept the plain mock-up theme visible as pending instead of dropping it. Retain.

  • RAILSPIKE.md Durable state and recovery: the Step 1 fields restored debug and study state in a new session without questions. Retain.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • step2_feature_description.md repeats the debug and effort pointers that RAILSPIKE.md already requires on step entry. Suggest one line linking both.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Documentation-only delivery scope fields: application change.

  • Follow-up Cycles Before Merge: no predecessor cycle.

Uncertain assessments

  • "≤1 page" and "no mockups": the artifact runs past a page because Step 1 handed two decisions to Step 2, and it links a mock-up canvas without embedding one. Whether a decisions section belongs in Step 2 or in a Step 1 revision is unclear.

  • Planning-commit rule: Step 1 was committed early by explicit exception; Step 2 is left uncommitted. The instructions do not say which rule a resumed cycle follows after such an exception.

  • R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session; recorded as such.

2026-11-16T03:00Z — Step 3

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step3_development_plan_do.md "Canonical components/API contracts touched" per stage: forced a read of ThreadRepository::replyPostsByThreadId, which showed thread rows already carry body, retracted_at, attribution_counted and author_identity_id. The totals reader needs no query. Retain.

  • step3_development_plan_do.md Completion Contract, release condition: kept the iPhone SE check visible as pending instead of implied by tests. Retain.

  • RAILSPIKE.md "do not manufacture approval from agent-authored scope": prompted recording the maintainer's delegation verbatim, with its boundary, before self-approving. Retain; consider naming delegated approval as a supported, labelled state.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • No supported findings.

Inapplicable instructions

  • step3_development_plan_after.md step 5 "Stop and wait": replaced for this cycle by the recorded delegation.

  • Known user replay stage: the named environment (iPhone SE on zenmemes.com) cannot be reached from this session; recorded as pending, not replayed.

Uncertain assessments

  • Whether "refinements within scope" (amount field instead of a switch; reason shown to all readers) should have returned to Step 2. Both were named or allowed by Step 2 text, so they were recorded in Step 3. With a self-approving agent this judgment has no second reader.

  • The plan runs over one page.

2026-11-16T03:15Z — Step 4

Necessary/useful instructions

  • step4_implementation_do.md Stage Boundary Protocol (verify, update summary, commit, then next stage): kept four reviewable commits in an unattended run with no human between stages. Retain.

  • implementation_standards.md "Complete the recorded outcome through its ordinary entry": running the flow in a browser found the amount field hidden in the collapsed reply box, which every PHP test had passed. Retain.

  • implementation_standards.md "Open the handoff with unverified outcomes": shaped the PR and the checklist around the pending iPhone check and the no-name finding. Retain.

  • AGENTS.md Tests: the smoke set plus named classes ran in about a minute per stage. Retain.

Redundant/unnecessary instructions

  • step4_implementation_before.md "Do not add the ledger or summary to the planning commit" while the organization rule asks for repaired references: the ledger's links to moved plans had to wait for the Stage 1 commit. Suggest allowing link-only ledger fixes in the planning commit.

Inapplicable instructions

  • Documentation-only verification rules.

  • AGENTS.md navigation icons, third-party code and retraction coordination: no navigation item, dependency or retraction change. (npm install fetched only the already declared playwright-core into the ignored node_modules/.)

Uncertain assessments

  • Delegated self-approval: every gate in this cycle after Step 1 was passed by its author. The gates still forced written decisions and a recorded boundary, but they did not supply a second reader. One consequential finding (a no-JavaScript pledge has no name, so it is not counted) follows from a Step 2 decision the author approved alone. Whether Railspike should name this mode, and require the handoff to list self-approved decisions, is for the maintainer.

  • The separate log-only commit after the final stage: followed as written.