Repository source: docs/plans/pledge_withdraw/pledge_withdraw_debug_log.md
Pledge withdraw debug log
2026-11-16T03:00Z — Step 1
Necessary/useful instructions
AGENTS.md"Current retraction coordination": the handoff's direction (make retraction simpler) became the main argument against a retraction-family withdrawal record. Retain.step1_solution_assessment.md"Understood Intent": gave a place to say that the spec's decided line predates the code check, without rewriting the request. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mdFollow-up Cycles Before Merge: prompted recording the parent cycle, the unmerged PR and the branch this plan sits on. Retain.RAILSPIKE.md"do not manufacture approval": the Status line states that cycle 1's delegation does not carry over. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
The
/new or /clearreminder's condition is met (discussion preceded this Step 1), and the maintainer asked for a new-chat prompt in the same message.
Uncertain assessments
Original Query: the request names no feature; the feature comes from the checklist. The query was kept whole and the checklist item quoted under Understood Intent.
"Keep Step 1 uncommitted": committed and pushed at the maintainer's explicit request, as in cycle 1.
Four options is the stated maximum; Option D is included because it is the spec's literal reading, although it does not meet the goal.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session.
2026-11-16T03:02Z — Step 2
Necessary/useful instructions
step2_feature_description.md"Shared component inventory": readingTagOnlyLeafFilterandRetractedLeafFilterfor it produced the fold rule and showed that undo already leaves no stub. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mdEnhancement Requests: gave the "author stops someone else's pledge counting" question a visible home once it was decided against for this cycle. Retain.step2_feature_description.mdRisks "earliest validation": turned two unknowns (viewer-only button on a static page, author match across keys) into checks to run before Step 3. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mddebug and effort recovery on resumption: state was restored from the Step 1 file in a new session with no questions needed. Retain.AGENTS.mdretraction coordination: the handoff was read; it confirmed that undo should use retraction unchanged. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
No supported findings.
Inapplicable instructions
"Known user or environment": no failure was reported; the release condition names the maintainer's iPhone SE as in cycle 1.
Documentation-only scope fields.
Uncertain assessments
"≤1 page": exceeded, as in cycle 1, because the maintainer asked for three Step 1 questions to be answered here. The decisions section could be a separate artifact type.
"Keep Steps 1–3 uncommitted": Step 1 is already committed on
plan/pledge-withdrawby request. Step 2 and the checklist, spec, ledger and log edits were left uncommitted this session pending the maintainer's word.The checklist and spec are not Railspike artifacts; rewording the spec's withdrawal lines followed Step 1 approval, not a step instruction.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session.
2026-11-16T05:08Z — Step 2 (Revision)
Revision of the Step 2 entry above, after the maintainer's review comment on decision 3.
Uncertain assessments
Step 1's handoff question "this cycle should only avoid blocking that rule" was answered in Step 2 with design groundwork (two amounts, general reply-line rules). The maintainer judged it overcomplicated and it was cut to one line. A deferred rule may need only a sentence saying which cycle owns it; Step 2's guardrail against implementation details already pointed that way.
2026-11-16T05:13Z — Step 3
Necessary/useful instructions
Step 2 Risks "earliest validation … before Step 3": both checks were run before drafting. One removed a risk (the button follows Retract's viewer test); the other became a stated limit (author match is per key). Retain.
step3_development_plan_do.md"Canonical components/API contracts touched" as its own bullet: forced a reason for a third leaf filter instead of extending one of the two. Retain.step3_development_plan_do.mdCompletion Contract "release condition": kept the iPhone SE check visibly pending. Retain.RAILSPIKE.mdFollow-up Cycles Before Merge withAGENTS.md"check that its PR is still open": produced the Branch section, since stacking on an unmerged branch needs the maintainer's request. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
step3_development_plan_before.mdrepeats debug and effort restoration already done at Step 2 in the same session. Low cost; could say "skip when unchanged in this session".
Inapplicable instructions
Replaying a reported user failure: none was reported.
Documentation-only fields; database change notes.
Uncertain assessments
"<=1 page": exceeded slightly by the findings and refinements sections, which have no named place in the Step 3 structure.
"<=50 lines of change" per stage: Stage 1 and Stage 3 may pass it once tests are counted.
Steps 2 and 3 and the bookkeeping edits remain uncommitted in a cloud workspace; whether that survives to Step 4 depends on the session.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session.
2026-11-16T05:44Z — Step 4
Necessary/useful instructions
AGENTS.md"before any push to an existing branch, check that its PR is still open": the check found PR #268 merged between Step 3's handoff and its approval, which settled Step 3's Branch question and moved the work to a new branch fromorigin/main. Retain.step4_implementation_before.mdplanning commit gate: kept Steps 1 to 3 and the folder move apart from code. Retain.Stage Boundary Protocol: each stage's tests and summary went into its own commit; the summary was easy to write while the stage was fresh. Retain.
implementation_standards.md"complete the outcome through its ordinary entry": led to extending the browser check with a real signed press and a forced failure, not only PHP rendering tests. Retain.Shared standards "inspect existing implementations": found that
submitSignedReplyFormToApiis not exposed and that the Outbox's prepare and finalize pair is, so no signing code changed. Retain.
Redundant/unnecessary instructions
The organization rule and the planning-commit allowance say in three places (Planning Artifacts, Commit discipline, Step 4 Before) what may be in the planning commit. One statement with two links would do.
Inapplicable instructions
Follow-up Cycles Before Merge: prepared for in Step 3, then not needed because the parent PR merged.
Navigation icon rule; dependency approval; schema change requirements.
Uncertain assessments
The planning commit may not include the ledger, but this cycle's Step 1 commit (made earlier at the maintainer's request) already did. The later ledger, checklist and spec edits were held back from the planning commit and went in with Stage 1. The rule does not say what to do with non-Railspike planning files such as a multi-cycle checklist.
The main branch gained a related flag (count pledges with no name) after Step 3 was written. It was treated as new understanding within scope and recorded at entry. The instructions do not name a checkpoint for "the base moved between approval and Step 4".
A ledger edit failed silently in the Stage 1 commit script; the Step 4 entry line is therefore folded into the closeout entry.
R1 reference hashes were not re-verified this session.