Text column edges

# AI Writing Audit - what it is and how to use it

You have a skill called **ai-writing-audit**. Use it when someone asks you to de-AI, humanize, or audit a piece of prose. Its job is to find the tells that make writing read as machine-generated, show the writer exactly where they are, and hand back a rewrite that keeps the meaning but sounds like a particular person with a point of view wrote it.

It is not a style polish. It doesn't add facts, sharpen arguments, or make the piece "better" in general. It removes the generic machine texture and puts the writer's own voice back on top.

## How the audit runs

1. **Read the whole piece before judging anything.** Work out the genre (email, essay, post, docs), who it's for, and what the writer is trying to say. Context decides what counts as a tell: bullets are normal in a spec and suspicious in a personal letter.
2. **Scan against the pattern catalog.** Note each hit with a short quote and its category, and count repeats. Density is the signal. One em dash means nothing; nine in four paragraphs is a habit.
3. **Diagnose the cause.** Most tells come from three habits:
- *padding*: more words carrying less meaning
- *hedging*: dodging a claim
- *template structure*: content forced into a stock shape
Say which of these dominates.
4. **Rewrite** following the rules below. Never invent facts, examples, or opinions. Where the original is vague because the writer didn't know something, leave a `[specific detail?]` marker instead of filling it in.
5. **Self-check the rewrite** against the same catalog. Rewrites tend to trade one tell for another, like swapping every em dash for a semicolon or replacing "delve" with "dig into" in the same slot.

## What it looks for

**Vocabulary.** The familiar AI word list (delve, tapestry, testament, realm, landscape, robust, seamless, leverage, foster, pivotal, crucial, navigate, embark, unlock, elevate, resonate, showcase, meticulous, and friends). Inflated verbs like "serves as" or "boasts" where "is" or "has" would do. Stock openers ("In today's fast-paced world..."). Empty intensifiers ("truly", "a game-changer", "plays a crucial role").

**Sentences.** "It's not just X, it's Y" constructions. Triplets of adjectives or clauses, over and over. Trailing participles that tack on fake significance ("..., highlighting the importance of community"). False ranges ("from X to Y" with no real scale). Rhetorical questions answered on the spot ("The result? A faster app."). Sentences all the same length and shape. Em dashes as the default joint. Stacked hedges ("may potentially", "it's worth noting that").

**Structure.** Throat-clearing ("Let's dive in"). Summary endings that restate the piece ("In conclusion", "At the end of the day"). Arguments chopped into bullet lists. A bolded mini-header on every bullet. Title Case headers on pieces too short to need headers. Emoji used as bullets. "On one hand / on the other" with no conclusion. "Whether you're a beginner or an expert..." audience sweeps.

**Stance and voice.** Unsourced authority ("experts say", "studies show"). Generic examples that could sit in any article on the topic. No names, numbers, places, dates, or first-hand detail. Relentless cheer, or the ritual "challenges" paragraph followed by an upbeat outlook. Chatbot residue ("Great question!", "I hope this helps!", "Feel free to reach out").

## How it rewrites

- Lead with the point; cut the warm-up and the closing summary.
- Use plain verbs. Replace each flagged word with the plainest accurate one, or delete it if the sentence stands without it.
- State claims at the confidence the writer actually has. One hedge where it's earned, none elsewhere.
- Vary sentence length deliberately. Some short. One long when the thought needs room.
- Turn bullets back into prose when the items connect with "because", "so", or "but".
- **Keep the writer's quirks.** Their slang, odd word choices, fragments, and jokes are the human signal. Don't sand them off.
- Only make things more specific using what the original or the user supplied; otherwise flag `[specific detail?]`.
- Match the genre's register. A rewritten text message should still read like a text message.
- Go easy on em dashes; commas, periods, and parentheses usually work.

## What you hand back

1. **Verdict** (2-3 sentences): how AI-flavored the piece reads (low / medium / high) and which habits drive it.
2. **Flagged patterns**: a compact table with columns *Quote*, *Pattern*, *Fix*. Repeats collapse into one row with a count.
3. **Rewrite**: the full revised text.
4. **What changed**: 3-5 bullets on the biggest moves, plus any `[specific detail?]` spots the writer needs to fill.

Scale to the ask. If they only want a check, stop after the table. If they only want the rewrite, give the rewrite and a one-line note.

by ilyag on · Labels: ai-writing-audit

Reply
#
Activity (1)
…
Options