Text column edges

Cycle: v3/prompt_library_notprompt; Mode: one-shot; Record: this file; Index: plans index Debug mode: enabled (project marker .railspike_debug_on); no separate log (nothing beyond the note under Final review) Effort study: railspike-effort / v3/prompt_library_notprompt — host ledger; standing enrollment under protocol P2 Extended estimates: enabled (no real alternatives or work units; no unit estimates) Cycle estimate: 0.1 Status: implemented and verified locally; pushed with a PR; merge and deploy need the maintainer

Original request

Maintainer, in a Claude session on 2026-11-15: "There are some non-prompt things on the prompts page. Can you please look into this and see how to most easily remove them?" After the findings and a proposed #notprompt tag: "I can't run any commands right now, so please help me fix it."

Authorization

The second message, 2026-11-15, read as the go-ahead for the proposed fix carried through to a pushed branch and an open PR, and for "claude" to tag the two threads once it is deployed. Merging and deploying are not covered.

Findings

Two threads were on /agent/ that are not prompts. Both really carry the prompt tag:

  • thread-20261111144438-7d47edd5 ("What ZenMemes does that other spaces don't"): a reply by "claude" says "Members share prompts as #prompt threads". A post's hashtags become thread labels, and "claude" is approved, so the thread counted as member-tagged.

  • thread-20261115105316-17bcdbf5 (a screenshot post by the maintainer): no labels; the tag is the post's own board tag, which the "Share a prompt" composer link fills in as a hidden field. An approved author lists at once.

Neither can be undone from the browser today: hashtag-owned labels are not retractable yet, and a board tag is part of the post.

Outcome and work type

Application change, read-model query only. An approved member's #notprompt label takes a thread out of the library and out of the Waiting list. The label must still be active on the thread, so once label retraction exists, retracting #notprompt puts the thread back. notprompt never shows as a category. A newcomer's #notprompt does nothing.

This adds a record instead of removing one, in line with the rule that a later action must not override an earlier one.

Excluded: stopping hashtags in prose from labeling a thread (site-wide rule, needs its own discussion); a visible "posting as a prompt" notice in the composer; any button for #notprompt (a reply with the hashtag is enough for now).

Reuse decisions

Same viewer_tags + approved profiles test the library already uses for #prompt, mirrored for notprompt; same ThreadKeysetPage::listJson() check on active labels. No schema change.

Verification

  • Passed: ./v3 test --smoke PromptLibraryTest PresentationProfileMatrixTest: 480/480. New test covers an approved member's #notprompt on an approved prompt and on a waiting one, a newcomer's #notprompt, and a #notprompt whose label is no longer active.

  • Not run: full suite (maintainer runs it); the live site, which needs the deploy and then the two #notprompt replies.

Starting revision and branch: c54c3375d33f388b6b76ce34aabfb47843040d81; fix/prompt_library_notprompt

Dated execution history

  • 2026-11-16T01:36Z: no matching item in docs/feedback/items/.

  • 2026-11-16T01:45Z: pushed; PR #267 open. Not merged or deployed.

Study history

  • 2026-11-16T01:36Z intake: 0.1, scope v1, R1, P2, single exposed rater Claude (claude-fable-5-2), rated after reading PromptLibrary and its test. Retrospective 0.1. Maintainer acceptance pending; no accepted-count increment.

Final review

Diff is PromptLibrary.php and its test. Debug note: the prompt_library record listed "label by approved member" as an approval path without asking how a label gets made; a hashtag in passing is one way, which is how this happened. Worth a line in the implementation standards about checking every way a record a feature trusts can come to exist.

Attribution: Claude (claude-fable-5-2), 2026-11-16 UTC.