I checked the verses and the factual claims. The citations are right and the post hedges fairly, but a few translation choices lean toward "prediction," and one statistic is inflated.
Malachi 1:11 has no verb. The Hebrew reads literally "great My name among the nations." JPS translates it in the present tense ("My name is great"), and the Talmud (Menachot 110a) reads it as describing Malachi's own day. Reading it as a future prophecy is an interpretive choice, and the argument in section 1 depends on that choice.
"Read in thousands of languages" is too high for the Hebrew Scriptures. Per Wycliffe's August 2025 figures, the full Bible exists in 776 languages. Another 1,798 have only the New Testament, and 1,433 have portions, mostly Gospels. For the Hebrew Bible, "hundreds of languages" is accurate.
Isaiah 49 names the servant. Verse 3 says outright: "You are My servant, Israel." So the Jewish reading isn't just a long-standing interpretation; it's in the text. The usual Christian answer is that in verses 5–6 the servant restores Israel and so must be someone else. Both points belong in the discussion.
Genesis 12:3 and 22:18 are ambiguous. The verbs (nivrechu, hitbarechu) can mean "be blessed" or "bless themselves by you," i.e. the nations will use Abraham's name when they bless each other. JPS renders 22:18 as "bless themselves." Also, 22:18 is about Abraham's offspring, not Abraham himself.
Islam is missing. About 2 billion Muslims worship the God of Abraham, and that spread didn't come through Christianity. "Billions revere Jesus" still holds, since Muslims count him as a prophet. But Christianity is one of two main routes by which Israel's God became known worldwide, not the only one.
"Independently of the New Testament" is partly true. The crucifixion under Pilate is attested by Tacitus (Annals 15.44) and Josephus. The closer parallels to Isaiah 53, like the silent lamb and suffering for others' sins, come from the Gospels and Christian theology.
What checks out: the summary of Isaiah 52:13–53:12 is accurate, and these texts predate Christianity (the Great Isaiah Scroll from Qumran, around the 2nd century BCE, contains chapter 53). Isaiah 2:4 is correctly flagged as unfulfilled. The dominant medieval Jewish reading of the servant as Israel (Rashi, Ibn Ezra, Radak) is stated correctly, though some older sources read it messianically: Targum Jonathan applies 52:13 to the Messiah, and the Talmud takes up the idea in Sanhedrin 98b. One Jewish objection the post could anticipate is that "offspring" (zera) in 53:10 normally means biological children.
Sources: